Yesterday was Premiere Day of Terminator Salvation in Beijing. As big, big fans of this franchise, my father and I went to see a late (10:30pm) screening. (We had wanted to see an earlier showing, but tickets were sold out.) The theater was packed. The effects were spectacular on the big screen. But ultimately we both left the showing somewhat disappointed.
To give you some perspective – I have always regarded the Terminator series as one of the best science fiction franchises ever made. I think I first saw Terminator some 16 years ago, around 1993. I couldn’t fully appreciate it at the time (since I was only 10 years old), but the gritty, violent and graphic depiction left a deep impression. Then I saw T2 in 1994. Those two films, along with a few other select films (the first two films of the Alien franchise, The Abyss – yes, a lot of James Cameron films), defined my early taste for science fiction, and perhaps even broadly films in general. I would always love dark, apocalyptic scenarios (if just to remind us how good we have it going now), and the relationship between man and machine / technology and civilization would always fascinate me.
Oh, and did I say that Terminator 2: Judgment Day is one of the best films, ever?
Okay. Having paid my homage to the franchise, it’s now time to comment on the latest installment. After the disappointing-but-expected Terminator 3 in 2003 (that was a fun summer tentpole flick, but doesn’t live up to the franchise’s proud history, and its disappointment was to be expected, given what I had read about its production process), the Salvation project gained a lot of anticipation and was heavily hyped up. Everyone loved the images released. McG and crew definitely got the visuals right – finally, this is the apocalyptic future that the series has always alluded to but never fully visualized. And the cast inspires confidence – Christian Bale is one of the biggest names around these days, and his success with Christopher Nolan and the Batman franchise reboot just gives us a lot of room to imagine what good things may happen to this film.
And for the opening half of the film, I was fully engrossed. Although everybody knew beforehand that Sam Worthington’s character, Marcus Wright, is a cyborg who believes he’s human, there was still ample tension to the plot. When would he realize his condition? And how would that affect his actions?
The first half of the film is very much an origin story. We discover Kyle Reese (played by Anton Yelchin, who has that delicious role as Chekov in the latest Star Trek), who as fans of the franchise know, would be the father of John Connor, after he is sent back in time to protect Sarah Connor. And to a certain extent, we discover John Connor, who we’ve only seen as a child and a young man in previous films. Here he is finally the leader of the resistance.
Marcus Wright is the link between these two pivotal characters, whose narratives are developed in parallel right until the final climax. While this is a promising setup, the plot ultimately does not culminate into something that satisfies the build-up. The second half of the film gradually results in a rescue mission by John Connor to save his future father, with Marcus giving him ample assistance. I was hoping for some more meaningful interaction between father and son.
I did a quick scan of the major reviews on RottenTomatoes last night. Seems like most critics reached consensus on how “programmed” and “robotic” this film was. I think this is somewhat harsh – the narrative is routine, and there’s no surprise ending, but the origin story is still solid. I do agree with someone’s observation that the lack of a central, identifiable antagonist was a major issue why this film lacked tension. Because there are so many terminators, the threat level of every single one of them has dropped dramatically – make no mistake, they are hard to kill, but the audience knows that the protagonists won’t die at the hand of an ordinary terminator. This is why the Governator’s ultra-high-profile late cameo (via the wizardry of CG) is such a delightful final twist – finally we have a bad guy that is a match for the good guys.
In terms of the action, the film pays ample homage to the proud traditions of the franchise. The motorbike, the truck (and the long chase sequences where these tools are employed), hand-to-hand combat, the rugged industrial setting (the factory in T1, the iron mill in T2, and here it’s the T-800 assembly line) are all there. Even the famous one-liners make a come-back. “Come with me if you want to live.” And of course, “I’ll be back.” Indeed, I felt the film was too soaked up and too occupied basking in the glory of old, and was not bold enough in striking its own place in the franchise – ultimately, this film adds nothing especially important to the Terminator-verse.
And I didn’t like some of the more cheesy settings that reminded me of the disastrous 2nd and 3rd installments of the Matrix trilogy. John Connor is called “the prophecy”; Marcus has a late scene where he encounters his makers, and it’s very much Neo vs. the Architect redux. (I hated the whole feel of that scene.)
The first two films of the franchise always had us pondering on the relationship between man and machine, and more importantly, what is the essence of humanity. Arnold Schwarzenegger’s terminator in the second film gradually understood human emotions – “I know now why you cry, but it’s something I can never do.” (hmmm, one of the best tear-jerking lines for guys?) In Salvation, Marcus Wright steps up to take this role. Here is a cyborg with a human heart, and real human memories – this is a man who’s literally given a new body – and this is certainly the ultimate existential observation: we are human not because of our flesh, but because of our soul. It’s an interesting premise, but the film doesn’t use it fully at all, only resorting to the cliched plot device of letting the robot sacrifice himself in the name of humanity. Marcus’s inner struggle, which could have been a very powerful narrative, is too hastily touched upon, and that deprives the film of real emotions.
6/10
dani19 Films Films
Recent Comments